After spending two years caring for her younger siblings, Maggie Fisher dreams of a family of her own-but will it ever happen? Can her two spinster Aunts use their matchmaking skills to find her a suitable husband? Challenged by the pull Henry Schrock has on her, Maggie finds herself drawn to his boyish charm. Will the handsome businessman from Elkhart, Indiana, capture her heart, or will he leave it tattered and torn with lost hopes of finding someone special? When a new project looms to exploit their quiet Old-Order Amish Community, can Maggie put her feelings aside to help Henry save the town from business tycoon, George Waldorf? Will Maggie's love of baking not only fill the Apple Blossom Inn with guests but save Willow Springs? When it looks like love may bloom for her at last, Maggie catches Henry in a compromising situation that forces her to make plans to run back to Wisconsin, instead of following her heart.